Procol HarumBeyond
|
|
PH on stage | PH on record | PH in print | BtP features | What's new | Interact with BtP | For sale | Site search | Home |
Each day we added three statements to the following list. Not all the statements were true! All you needed to do was make a note, from day to day, of the number of any statement that you considered to be true. Some days there were one true statement, some days there were more than one. There were never zero, and there were fifteen correct statements altogether. Detailed 'how to play' instructions were here.
We hope you didn't make any hasty decisions. There might have been small inaccuracies in an otherwise-faultless statement; and if there were, that whole statement was untrue overall. We might well have taken something that looks true, and mischievously distorted it by changing some tiny detail. And we might have selected something that looked deeply improbable, but was in fact correct in every particular.
Here are the answers, which almost every competitor must have got right, since almost all the Ultimate Answers we received were correct. Sorry it was so painfully straightforward ... won't happen again!
25 December
|
1 |
|
This is true, as Mick himself relates here |
2 |
|
This is also true: one date at the end of May, another at the start of June – see here | |
3 |
|
This is not one of the legitimate explanations for the entitling of this excellent album. | |
26 December
|
4 |
|
This is not true: Procol Harum did use two guitarists at this show, but as the set list shows, Grabham and Whitehorn occasionally played together, which would have been a clumsy prospect had they been sharing a single instrument. |
5 |
|
Perfectly correct: thanks to Chris Copping for clarifying the date of this gig (here). | |
6 |
|
As far as we know, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in Cleveland, Ohio has not been firebombed, despite its unwillingness to elect Procol Harum. | |
27 December
|
7 |
|
A glance at the cover of the Live at Edmonton album shows evidence of no such garment – which in any case sounds like an insult to sartorial sensibilities. |
8 |
|
He certainly does: on 15 December here. Riddley Walker is the Whiter-Shade-of-Pale-moment in the career of this brilliant Anglo-American novelist, who died so recently: completely uncharacteristic, utterly unforgettable, and tending to overshadow the excellence of so much of the other work. Readers of 'Beyond the Pale' are strongly advised to investigate! | |
9 |
|
Untrue: Procol's only volcanic gig took place in a long-extinct crater at Dalhalla, Sweden. | |
28 December
|
10 |
|
Untrue: Sebastian Faulks does indeed mention Procol Harum in a novel, but it is Engleby. |
11 |
|
True: see here for confirmation. | |
12 |
|
Not quite true – see here; the extra words (with their colourful, nasal theme) to Keith Reid's lyric were supplied by Gary Brooker. | |
29 December
|
13 |
|
This is the case, as several interviews archived at 'Beyond the Pale' attest. |
14 |
|
This is also true – see
here; sadly the music was lost when a server went down, and Prof
Copping no longer has the original: 'Finding an old DAT that behaves and
a working machine to play it on is quite an ask these days,' he
observes. |
|
15 |
|
This is untrue, and is suspiciously like the statement about Mick Grabham that started this series of conundrums. | |
30 December
|
16 |
|
It is hard to call to mind a single Brooker / Reid instrumental, for obvious reasons. Seventeen albums'-worth seems entirely improbable. |
17 |
|
Indeed he did, as is recorded in A Faulty Log | |
18 |
|
Stuff and nonsense. | |
31 December
|
19 |
|
Josh's credits are far-ranging, but they do not include Friar Bacon and Friar Bungay as yet. |
20 |
|
Geoff's middle name is 'Edwin' but the word 'wined' does not occur in Grand Hotel; nor does 'widen'. Perhaps some of our more creative readers might enjoy devising an extra verse that does contain these words, and perhaps anagrams of other Procolers' middle names. | |
21 |
|
This is true – as a moment's Google search demonstrates. | |
1 January 2012
|
22 |
|
One of the reasons that this is not true is that there has been no such combination of day and date. |
23 |
|
This is verified at this page. | |
24 |
|
One of the reasons that this is not true is that there has been no such combination of day and date. | |
2 January
|
25 |
|
This is true: it appears to be a fragment of The Poet, before it was worked out for performance, and a good while before it was committed to record as Without a Doubt. |
26 |
|
This is nearly true, except that the dates are quoted incorrectly, and Helen Mirren grew up in Essex, not Wessex. | |
27 |
|
Quite the opposite: see here | |
3 January
|
28 |
|
'All this is so' (to quote Act IV, scene 1, line 125 of MacBeth by William Shakespeare). Illustrations are here |
29 |
|
This is true, although it may be hard to imagine why anybody would want such a publication. | |
30 |
|
The quotation – referring to BJ Wilson – comes from an interview given by someone who probably rehearsed with Procol Harum in the very earliest days, but did not perform with them. | |
4 January
|
31 |
|
This is too silly to merit any comment whatever. |
32 |
|
This is not true: the Procol Harum online shop works in three currencies for customers' convenience, not four as shown here. | |
33 |
|
Precisely so, as indicated on this page and on this page. | |
5 January
|
34 |
|
There is no such church: 'Magner' is the former surname of Procol Harum's very amiable former roadie. |
35 |
|
True ... see here ... and we make no apology for sending you to that page, which contains a monster clue inasmuch as it reminds you of Douglas Adams and the number 42. | |
36 |
|
No they were not. They are two recording personnel whose names appear among the credits on the Exotic Birds and Fruit album, a.o. |
We asked you to write down the numbers of all the fifteen true statements above, add up the odd numbers (‘Total A’) and separately add up all the even numbers (‘Total B’).
Total A: 1 + 5 + 11 + 13 + 17 + 21 + 23
+ 25 + 29 + 33 + 35 = 213
Total B: 2 + 8 + 14 + 28 = 52
Next you had to find the separate ‘digital roots’ of Total A
and Total B.
Total A: 2 + 1 + 3 = 6
Total B: 5 + 2 = 7
The two single-digit numbers, derived from Total A and Total B, were to be converted into letters of the alphabet, using the system A=1, B=2, C=3 … etc.
Total A: 6 =
F
Total B: 7 = G
Now you had to find the only Procol Harum song that has those two letters as its initials:
Fools Gold
(In the worked example, the letters derived from the two Totals were ‘D’ and ‘A’:
for Douglas Adams, part of whose name is also visible in the page-background)
We asked you to write down the two words of the title separately, and find a number-value for each word, again using the system A=1, B=2, C=3 etc.
F + O + O + L + S = 6 + 15 + 15 + 12 + 19 = 67
G + O + L + D = 7 + 15 + 12 + 4 = 38
Now you had to take these two numbers derived from the title-words and work out their digital roots
6 + 7 = 13; 1 + 3 =
4
3 + 8 = 11; 1 + 1 = 2
Lastly, you had to put the two numbers side-by-side to make a two-digit number ... the answer is 42 ... which is the same as the answer to our last quiz, by an astonishing coincidence, perhaps.
If you were in the quickest three correct entrants (on a beat-the-clock basis) you got your prime choice of the prizes. After that, all correct entries received in the following 24 hours – and they were almost all correct this year, so trivially easy were the questions – were placed in the BtP Homburg, and the remaining winners were drawn by a suitably Glamorous Assistant (subject to taste).
2011 puzzle prizes | Winners | How to play |
PH on stage | PH on record | PH in print | BtP features | What's new | Interact with BtP | For sale | Site search | Home |