LONDON - The lead singer of the British band Procol Harum won an appeals
court judgment Friday awarding him the full royalties to the iconic hit,
A Whiter Shade of Pale.
Britain's Court of Appeal ruling for rock star Gary Brooker overturned a
lower court decision granting the group's former organist 40 percent of the
millions of dollars in royalties from the song.
The appeals court agreed Matthew Fisher, who played the haunting organ
theme, was entitled to co-authorship but said he will receive no money from
past or future royalties.
"For
nearly three years this claim has been a great strain upon myself and my
family. I believe the original trial was unfair and the results wrong,"
Brooker said. "I would hope
that now, we can
all get on with our lives."
Lord Justice John Mummery said Fisher was "guilty of excessive and
inexcusable delay in asserting his claim."
Fisher, who quit the band in 1969 and is now a computer programmer in
London, filed his claim to joint ownership nearly 40 years after the song
was recorded and became one of the anthems of the
1967 "Summer of Love." The record has sold 10 million copies, and Rolling
Stone magazine has ranked the song 57th on a list of the 500 greatest of all
time.
Brooker argued that it was his idea to use the theme based on Bach's Air
on the G String that Fisher played on the track, and that he was unable
to make his case properly because Fisher did not
tell him he was pursuing his legal claim.
Brooker, who still tours with the band, said he and lyricist Keith Reid
wrote the song before Fisher joined the band in March 1967.
The two had called Fisher's earlier court victory a dangerous precedent,
saying it meant any musician who had played on any recording in the past
four decades could claim joint authorship.
The judge rejected Fisher's claim for an estimated $2 million in back
royalties.
Mummery said the issue of who will pay legal costs will be decided later, as
well as whether Fisher can appeal the decision to the House of Lords,
Britain's highest court.
In December, a judge awarded the classically trained Fisher a 40 percent
share in the copyright of the song, saying his organ solo was "a distinctive
and significant contribution to the overall
composition."
A Whiter Shade of Pale, famous for its cryptic lyrics — "We skipped
the light fandango, turned cartwheels 'cross the floor" — topped the British
charts for five weeks in 1967 and was a top five
hit in the US